How to Increase Recurring Giving at Your Church: 8 Plays That Work in 2026
What if a few small changes could dramatically increase consistent giving at your church? This article breaks down the simple rhythms, messaging shifts, and follow-up strategies churches are using to turn occasional donors into faithful recurring givers—without pressure, gimmicks, or big campaigns.
Consider this story about a pastor in the Midwest. His church had been flat on giving for two years. Not declining, just flat. He sat down one Sunday afternoon, looked at his giving dashboard, and noticed something simple: only 14% of his regular attenders had a recurring gift on file. He spent the next thirty days doing four very specific things, and by the end of the quarter, that number was 27%. Same congregation. Same income. Different rhythm.
That's the entire premise of this article. Recurring giving is not a personality trait that some churches have, and others don't. It's a habit you can teach, a friction you can remove, and a story you can tell week after week. And the leverage is real: as we walked through in the power of recurring giving, recurring givers contribute roughly 2.2x more annually than one-time givers. Same families. Different cadence.
What follows are eight plays ordered roughly from highest leverage to lowest lift, plus a 30-day rollout you can start this Sunday. None of this is theory. It's how local pastors are actually moving the needle in 2026.
1. Ask directly, every week
The single biggest reason people don't set up recurring giving is that no one has ever asked them to. Not as a guilt trip. Not as a campaign. Just as a normal, weekly part of how your church talks about generosity.
Two scripts to steal:
From the stage (15 seconds before the offering):
“If you call this place home and you're giving today, would you take 60 seconds and set this up to repeat? It costs you nothing different, but it lets us plan the year in faith instead of guessing month to month. Pull out your phone. We'll wait.”
In the giving app or online form:
“This can be a one-time gift, or you can make it your monthly rhythm. Most of our regular givers go monthly. Want to try it?”
Both versions do the same job: they normalize recurring as the default, and they ask without flinching. For a deeper look at the cadence and channels, see our piece on why your church should regularly promote automated recurring giving.
2. Make consistency the message
Most generosity teaching focuses on the size of a gift. The bigger lever is its consistency. The math is striking, and it's not from a third-party study. It's straight from Tithely's own giving data across thousands of churches.
“The size of your gift will change with your season. Whether you give consistently doesn't have to.”
On average, one-time givers contribute about $1,245 per year. Recurring givers contribute about $2,739 per year. The median split is even sharper: $204 vs. $1,228. Same families. Different cadence. We unpacked the full picture in the power of recurring giving. Link to it from a sermon series page or send it as a follow-up email to anyone who responds to the offering moment.
When you preach on giving, lead with consistency, not amount. “The size of your gift will change with your season. Whether you give consistently doesn't have to.” That one line, repeated four Sundays a year, reshapes how a congregation thinks about their offering.
3. Frame the theology in 90 seconds
You don't need a six-week sermon series to ground recurring giving in scripture. You need a clear, brief framing that you return to often.
Recurring giving is the natural shape of a generous heart. Every harvest cycle in the Old Testament was rhythmic. The early church in Acts gave “as they had need” week by week, not in a burst. Paul tells the Corinthians to set aside something “on the first day of every week” (1 Corinthians 16:2). The biblical pattern for giving is regular, planned, and joyful.
Then point readers and listeners to the deeper studies. We have a comprehensive look at what the New Testament says about tithing, and a practical resource of scriptures about giving you can drop into a bulletin, a small group guide, or a monthly stewardship email.
4. Tell the story behind the gift
Numbers move analysts. Stories move congregations. Every quarter, find one giver in your church who set up a recurring gift in the last 90 days and ask them three questions on camera:
- “What was happening in your life when you decided to set this up?”
- “What did you learn about yourself or your faith once it started?”
- “What would you say to someone who's thinking about it but hasn't pulled the trigger?”
Edit it down to 60 seconds. Play it before the offering. Post it as a Reel. Email it to your list with a single subject line: “Why Sarah gives every month.” Stories do the asking for you, and they answer the unspoken hesitations no sermon ever quite covers.
5. Build a multichannel promotion rhythm
If recurring giving only shows up in announcements, you'll get the attendance you expect. The churches that move this number treat recurring giving the way they treat their Easter campaign: planned, multi-channel, sustained.
A simple 30-day cadence:
Multichannel doesn't mean noisy. It means present.
6. Remove every ounce of friction
Every extra tap is a tax on generosity. The churches that grow recurring giving the fastest are usually the ones that have been the most ruthless about removing the small obstacles between an intention and a transaction.
Make it easy to set up
Set up should take under 60 seconds and should never require leaving your app or your giving page. If your current online giving for churches tool requires an account, a verification email, and a confirmation step before someone can give, you're losing givers in the gap. Look at your flow on a phone. If you can't complete a recurring gift in three thumb taps, your tool is the bottleneck.
Make it easy to change
Givers should be able to update their amount, switch from card to ACH, or pause a gift on their own, without emailing the church office. The mental cost of “I'll have to call someone” is enough to keep a generous person from increasing their gift. Don't give them that excuse.
Make it easy to cancel
This sounds counterintuitive. It isn't. Givers who know they can cancel in two taps are more likely to set up recurring gifts. The churches that hide the cancel button get the same number of cancellations; they just get fewer recurring gifts to start with.
Cover the fees, where you can
Many givers will happily cover transaction fees if you let them. Tithely's Cover the Fees™ option presents that choice at the moment of the gift. In our data, more than 80% of givers opt in when asked. That's a small UX choice with a real budget impact.
ACH vs. card and what to do when payments fail
ACH is cheaper for the church, but slower. The card is faster, but it expires. The pragmatic answer is: offer both, default to whatever your congregation prefers, and mitigate the painful part of failed payments. Set up automated retry logic, an email to the giver when a card expires, and a quarterly report so your finance team isn't surprised. A failed recurring payment is not the end of a recurring relationship unless your system silently lets it die.
7. Activate first-time givers within Seven days
The first seven days after someone gives for the first time is the most overlooked window in church generosity. Most one-time givers never give again, not because they didn't mean to, but because nothing happened to bring them back. Your job is to send the right three messages while generosity is still stirring in their heart.
- Day 1: Thank them. Personally. By name. From the pastor, not from the system. A two-line email beats a templated receipt.
- Day 3: Tell a story. Send one short story about what their gift made possible. Specific. Recent. Concrete.
- Day 7: Make the soft ask. “If this place is becoming home for you, would you consider making this monthly? It's two taps, and you can change it any time.”
This sequence is not a marketing funnel. It's pastoral care that takes generosity seriously. Once you set it up, it runs in the background and steadily turns first-time givers into committed monthly partners.
8. Measure and revisit quarterly
You cannot grow what you do not watch. Three numbers—and only three—tell you whether recurring giving is working at your church:
- Recurring giver count: how many active recurring gifts do you have today?
- Recurring share of total giving: of every dollar that came in this month, how many cents were recurring?
- Average recurring gift: Is the size of your typical recurring gift growing, flat, or shrinking?
Pull these every quarter. Pick one to move next quarter. Run one experiment with a new “ask” script, a new channel, and a new first-gift sequence. Measure it against your baseline. Repeat. Most churches that try to optimize everything end up moving nothing; the ones that pick a single number per quarter compound their gains over a year.
Your 30-day recurring-giving rollout
If you only have a month, do this:
- Week 1: Launch the ask. Add the recurring ask script to every offering moment and start collecting one giver story.
- Week 2: Email every one-time giver from the last 90 days with a direct invitation to make their gift recurring.
- Week 3: Add a push notification, a bulletin insert, and a foyer QR card. Launch a second story.
- Week 4: Measure. Whatever channel produced the most new recurring givers, do twice as much of it next month.
Where to go from here
Recurring giving is not a software problem. It's a leadership rhythm. Your tools should make the rhythm easier, not add another thing for your team to manage.
If your current giving setup is the pain point, consider Tithely's online giving for churches. Setup is free, recurring is built in, Cover the Fees™ is one toggle, and your finance team gets the reporting it actually needs.
And if you haven't yet, read the power of recurring giving for churches. It's the why behind everything in this guide.
FREE Download
A Recurring Giving Guide to Strengthen Discipleship and Ministry
Packed with actionable steps, real-life examples, and teaching moments, this resource equips church leaders to build a culture of consistent, year-round giving rooted in discipleship.
Download Now
Keep reading
- The Power of Recurring Giving for Churches
- How to Beat the Summer Giving Slump with Recurring Donations
- Tithing in the New Testament: What Does It Say?
- Online Giving for Churches · the tool that powers the rhythm
Sign Up for Product Updates
Chris Dunagan is a marketing strategist focused on church tech and digital engagement. He helps churches grow through SEO, email campaigns, and tools like Tithely and Breeze ChMS, with an emphasis on online giving, content strategy, and digital outreach.
Consider this story about a pastor in the Midwest. His church had been flat on giving for two years. Not declining, just flat. He sat down one Sunday afternoon, looked at his giving dashboard, and noticed something simple: only 14% of his regular attenders had a recurring gift on file. He spent the next thirty days doing four very specific things, and by the end of the quarter, that number was 27%. Same congregation. Same income. Different rhythm.
That's the entire premise of this article. Recurring giving is not a personality trait that some churches have, and others don't. It's a habit you can teach, a friction you can remove, and a story you can tell week after week. And the leverage is real: as we walked through in the power of recurring giving, recurring givers contribute roughly 2.2x more annually than one-time givers. Same families. Different cadence.
What follows are eight plays ordered roughly from highest leverage to lowest lift, plus a 30-day rollout you can start this Sunday. None of this is theory. It's how local pastors are actually moving the needle in 2026.
1. Ask directly, every week
The single biggest reason people don't set up recurring giving is that no one has ever asked them to. Not as a guilt trip. Not as a campaign. Just as a normal, weekly part of how your church talks about generosity.
Two scripts to steal:
From the stage (15 seconds before the offering):
“If you call this place home and you're giving today, would you take 60 seconds and set this up to repeat? It costs you nothing different, but it lets us plan the year in faith instead of guessing month to month. Pull out your phone. We'll wait.”
In the giving app or online form:
“This can be a one-time gift, or you can make it your monthly rhythm. Most of our regular givers go monthly. Want to try it?”
Both versions do the same job: they normalize recurring as the default, and they ask without flinching. For a deeper look at the cadence and channels, see our piece on why your church should regularly promote automated recurring giving.
2. Make consistency the message
Most generosity teaching focuses on the size of a gift. The bigger lever is its consistency. The math is striking, and it's not from a third-party study. It's straight from Tithely's own giving data across thousands of churches.
“The size of your gift will change with your season. Whether you give consistently doesn't have to.”
On average, one-time givers contribute about $1,245 per year. Recurring givers contribute about $2,739 per year. The median split is even sharper: $204 vs. $1,228. Same families. Different cadence. We unpacked the full picture in the power of recurring giving. Link to it from a sermon series page or send it as a follow-up email to anyone who responds to the offering moment.
When you preach on giving, lead with consistency, not amount. “The size of your gift will change with your season. Whether you give consistently doesn't have to.” That one line, repeated four Sundays a year, reshapes how a congregation thinks about their offering.
3. Frame the theology in 90 seconds
You don't need a six-week sermon series to ground recurring giving in scripture. You need a clear, brief framing that you return to often.
Recurring giving is the natural shape of a generous heart. Every harvest cycle in the Old Testament was rhythmic. The early church in Acts gave “as they had need” week by week, not in a burst. Paul tells the Corinthians to set aside something “on the first day of every week” (1 Corinthians 16:2). The biblical pattern for giving is regular, planned, and joyful.
Then point readers and listeners to the deeper studies. We have a comprehensive look at what the New Testament says about tithing, and a practical resource of scriptures about giving you can drop into a bulletin, a small group guide, or a monthly stewardship email.
4. Tell the story behind the gift
Numbers move analysts. Stories move congregations. Every quarter, find one giver in your church who set up a recurring gift in the last 90 days and ask them three questions on camera:
- “What was happening in your life when you decided to set this up?”
- “What did you learn about yourself or your faith once it started?”
- “What would you say to someone who's thinking about it but hasn't pulled the trigger?”
Edit it down to 60 seconds. Play it before the offering. Post it as a Reel. Email it to your list with a single subject line: “Why Sarah gives every month.” Stories do the asking for you, and they answer the unspoken hesitations no sermon ever quite covers.
5. Build a multichannel promotion rhythm
If recurring giving only shows up in announcements, you'll get the attendance you expect. The churches that move this number treat recurring giving the way they treat their Easter campaign: planned, multi-channel, sustained.
A simple 30-day cadence:
Multichannel doesn't mean noisy. It means present.
6. Remove every ounce of friction
Every extra tap is a tax on generosity. The churches that grow recurring giving the fastest are usually the ones that have been the most ruthless about removing the small obstacles between an intention and a transaction.
Make it easy to set up
Set up should take under 60 seconds and should never require leaving your app or your giving page. If your current online giving for churches tool requires an account, a verification email, and a confirmation step before someone can give, you're losing givers in the gap. Look at your flow on a phone. If you can't complete a recurring gift in three thumb taps, your tool is the bottleneck.
Make it easy to change
Givers should be able to update their amount, switch from card to ACH, or pause a gift on their own, without emailing the church office. The mental cost of “I'll have to call someone” is enough to keep a generous person from increasing their gift. Don't give them that excuse.
Make it easy to cancel
This sounds counterintuitive. It isn't. Givers who know they can cancel in two taps are more likely to set up recurring gifts. The churches that hide the cancel button get the same number of cancellations; they just get fewer recurring gifts to start with.
Cover the fees, where you can
Many givers will happily cover transaction fees if you let them. Tithely's Cover the Fees™ option presents that choice at the moment of the gift. In our data, more than 80% of givers opt in when asked. That's a small UX choice with a real budget impact.
ACH vs. card and what to do when payments fail
ACH is cheaper for the church, but slower. The card is faster, but it expires. The pragmatic answer is: offer both, default to whatever your congregation prefers, and mitigate the painful part of failed payments. Set up automated retry logic, an email to the giver when a card expires, and a quarterly report so your finance team isn't surprised. A failed recurring payment is not the end of a recurring relationship unless your system silently lets it die.
7. Activate first-time givers within Seven days
The first seven days after someone gives for the first time is the most overlooked window in church generosity. Most one-time givers never give again, not because they didn't mean to, but because nothing happened to bring them back. Your job is to send the right three messages while generosity is still stirring in their heart.
- Day 1: Thank them. Personally. By name. From the pastor, not from the system. A two-line email beats a templated receipt.
- Day 3: Tell a story. Send one short story about what their gift made possible. Specific. Recent. Concrete.
- Day 7: Make the soft ask. “If this place is becoming home for you, would you consider making this monthly? It's two taps, and you can change it any time.”
This sequence is not a marketing funnel. It's pastoral care that takes generosity seriously. Once you set it up, it runs in the background and steadily turns first-time givers into committed monthly partners.
8. Measure and revisit quarterly
You cannot grow what you do not watch. Three numbers—and only three—tell you whether recurring giving is working at your church:
- Recurring giver count: how many active recurring gifts do you have today?
- Recurring share of total giving: of every dollar that came in this month, how many cents were recurring?
- Average recurring gift: Is the size of your typical recurring gift growing, flat, or shrinking?
Pull these every quarter. Pick one to move next quarter. Run one experiment with a new “ask” script, a new channel, and a new first-gift sequence. Measure it against your baseline. Repeat. Most churches that try to optimize everything end up moving nothing; the ones that pick a single number per quarter compound their gains over a year.
Your 30-day recurring-giving rollout
If you only have a month, do this:
- Week 1: Launch the ask. Add the recurring ask script to every offering moment and start collecting one giver story.
- Week 2: Email every one-time giver from the last 90 days with a direct invitation to make their gift recurring.
- Week 3: Add a push notification, a bulletin insert, and a foyer QR card. Launch a second story.
- Week 4: Measure. Whatever channel produced the most new recurring givers, do twice as much of it next month.
Where to go from here
Recurring giving is not a software problem. It's a leadership rhythm. Your tools should make the rhythm easier, not add another thing for your team to manage.
If your current giving setup is the pain point, consider Tithely's online giving for churches. Setup is free, recurring is built in, Cover the Fees™ is one toggle, and your finance team gets the reporting it actually needs.
And if you haven't yet, read the power of recurring giving for churches. It's the why behind everything in this guide.
FREE Download
A Recurring Giving Guide to Strengthen Discipleship and Ministry
Packed with actionable steps, real-life examples, and teaching moments, this resource equips church leaders to build a culture of consistent, year-round giving rooted in discipleship.
Download Now
Keep reading
- The Power of Recurring Giving for Churches
- How to Beat the Summer Giving Slump with Recurring Donations
- Tithing in the New Testament: What Does It Say?
- Online Giving for Churches · the tool that powers the rhythm
podcast transcript
Chris Dunagan is a marketing strategist focused on church tech and digital engagement. He helps churches grow through SEO, email campaigns, and tools like Tithely and Breeze ChMS, with an emphasis on online giving, content strategy, and digital outreach.
Consider this story about a pastor in the Midwest. His church had been flat on giving for two years. Not declining, just flat. He sat down one Sunday afternoon, looked at his giving dashboard, and noticed something simple: only 14% of his regular attenders had a recurring gift on file. He spent the next thirty days doing four very specific things, and by the end of the quarter, that number was 27%. Same congregation. Same income. Different rhythm.
That's the entire premise of this article. Recurring giving is not a personality trait that some churches have, and others don't. It's a habit you can teach, a friction you can remove, and a story you can tell week after week. And the leverage is real: as we walked through in the power of recurring giving, recurring givers contribute roughly 2.2x more annually than one-time givers. Same families. Different cadence.
What follows are eight plays ordered roughly from highest leverage to lowest lift, plus a 30-day rollout you can start this Sunday. None of this is theory. It's how local pastors are actually moving the needle in 2026.
1. Ask directly, every week
The single biggest reason people don't set up recurring giving is that no one has ever asked them to. Not as a guilt trip. Not as a campaign. Just as a normal, weekly part of how your church talks about generosity.
Two scripts to steal:
From the stage (15 seconds before the offering):
“If you call this place home and you're giving today, would you take 60 seconds and set this up to repeat? It costs you nothing different, but it lets us plan the year in faith instead of guessing month to month. Pull out your phone. We'll wait.”
In the giving app or online form:
“This can be a one-time gift, or you can make it your monthly rhythm. Most of our regular givers go monthly. Want to try it?”
Both versions do the same job: they normalize recurring as the default, and they ask without flinching. For a deeper look at the cadence and channels, see our piece on why your church should regularly promote automated recurring giving.
2. Make consistency the message
Most generosity teaching focuses on the size of a gift. The bigger lever is its consistency. The math is striking, and it's not from a third-party study. It's straight from Tithely's own giving data across thousands of churches.
“The size of your gift will change with your season. Whether you give consistently doesn't have to.”
On average, one-time givers contribute about $1,245 per year. Recurring givers contribute about $2,739 per year. The median split is even sharper: $204 vs. $1,228. Same families. Different cadence. We unpacked the full picture in the power of recurring giving. Link to it from a sermon series page or send it as a follow-up email to anyone who responds to the offering moment.
When you preach on giving, lead with consistency, not amount. “The size of your gift will change with your season. Whether you give consistently doesn't have to.” That one line, repeated four Sundays a year, reshapes how a congregation thinks about their offering.
3. Frame the theology in 90 seconds
You don't need a six-week sermon series to ground recurring giving in scripture. You need a clear, brief framing that you return to often.
Recurring giving is the natural shape of a generous heart. Every harvest cycle in the Old Testament was rhythmic. The early church in Acts gave “as they had need” week by week, not in a burst. Paul tells the Corinthians to set aside something “on the first day of every week” (1 Corinthians 16:2). The biblical pattern for giving is regular, planned, and joyful.
Then point readers and listeners to the deeper studies. We have a comprehensive look at what the New Testament says about tithing, and a practical resource of scriptures about giving you can drop into a bulletin, a small group guide, or a monthly stewardship email.
4. Tell the story behind the gift
Numbers move analysts. Stories move congregations. Every quarter, find one giver in your church who set up a recurring gift in the last 90 days and ask them three questions on camera:
- “What was happening in your life when you decided to set this up?”
- “What did you learn about yourself or your faith once it started?”
- “What would you say to someone who's thinking about it but hasn't pulled the trigger?”
Edit it down to 60 seconds. Play it before the offering. Post it as a Reel. Email it to your list with a single subject line: “Why Sarah gives every month.” Stories do the asking for you, and they answer the unspoken hesitations no sermon ever quite covers.
5. Build a multichannel promotion rhythm
If recurring giving only shows up in announcements, you'll get the attendance you expect. The churches that move this number treat recurring giving the way they treat their Easter campaign: planned, multi-channel, sustained.
A simple 30-day cadence:
Multichannel doesn't mean noisy. It means present.
6. Remove every ounce of friction
Every extra tap is a tax on generosity. The churches that grow recurring giving the fastest are usually the ones that have been the most ruthless about removing the small obstacles between an intention and a transaction.
Make it easy to set up
Set up should take under 60 seconds and should never require leaving your app or your giving page. If your current online giving for churches tool requires an account, a verification email, and a confirmation step before someone can give, you're losing givers in the gap. Look at your flow on a phone. If you can't complete a recurring gift in three thumb taps, your tool is the bottleneck.
Make it easy to change
Givers should be able to update their amount, switch from card to ACH, or pause a gift on their own, without emailing the church office. The mental cost of “I'll have to call someone” is enough to keep a generous person from increasing their gift. Don't give them that excuse.
Make it easy to cancel
This sounds counterintuitive. It isn't. Givers who know they can cancel in two taps are more likely to set up recurring gifts. The churches that hide the cancel button get the same number of cancellations; they just get fewer recurring gifts to start with.
Cover the fees, where you can
Many givers will happily cover transaction fees if you let them. Tithely's Cover the Fees™ option presents that choice at the moment of the gift. In our data, more than 80% of givers opt in when asked. That's a small UX choice with a real budget impact.
ACH vs. card and what to do when payments fail
ACH is cheaper for the church, but slower. The card is faster, but it expires. The pragmatic answer is: offer both, default to whatever your congregation prefers, and mitigate the painful part of failed payments. Set up automated retry logic, an email to the giver when a card expires, and a quarterly report so your finance team isn't surprised. A failed recurring payment is not the end of a recurring relationship unless your system silently lets it die.
7. Activate first-time givers within Seven days
The first seven days after someone gives for the first time is the most overlooked window in church generosity. Most one-time givers never give again, not because they didn't mean to, but because nothing happened to bring them back. Your job is to send the right three messages while generosity is still stirring in their heart.
- Day 1: Thank them. Personally. By name. From the pastor, not from the system. A two-line email beats a templated receipt.
- Day 3: Tell a story. Send one short story about what their gift made possible. Specific. Recent. Concrete.
- Day 7: Make the soft ask. “If this place is becoming home for you, would you consider making this monthly? It's two taps, and you can change it any time.”
This sequence is not a marketing funnel. It's pastoral care that takes generosity seriously. Once you set it up, it runs in the background and steadily turns first-time givers into committed monthly partners.
8. Measure and revisit quarterly
You cannot grow what you do not watch. Three numbers—and only three—tell you whether recurring giving is working at your church:
- Recurring giver count: how many active recurring gifts do you have today?
- Recurring share of total giving: of every dollar that came in this month, how many cents were recurring?
- Average recurring gift: Is the size of your typical recurring gift growing, flat, or shrinking?
Pull these every quarter. Pick one to move next quarter. Run one experiment with a new “ask” script, a new channel, and a new first-gift sequence. Measure it against your baseline. Repeat. Most churches that try to optimize everything end up moving nothing; the ones that pick a single number per quarter compound their gains over a year.
Your 30-day recurring-giving rollout
If you only have a month, do this:
- Week 1: Launch the ask. Add the recurring ask script to every offering moment and start collecting one giver story.
- Week 2: Email every one-time giver from the last 90 days with a direct invitation to make their gift recurring.
- Week 3: Add a push notification, a bulletin insert, and a foyer QR card. Launch a second story.
- Week 4: Measure. Whatever channel produced the most new recurring givers, do twice as much of it next month.
Where to go from here
Recurring giving is not a software problem. It's a leadership rhythm. Your tools should make the rhythm easier, not add another thing for your team to manage.
If your current giving setup is the pain point, consider Tithely's online giving for churches. Setup is free, recurring is built in, Cover the Fees™ is one toggle, and your finance team gets the reporting it actually needs.
And if you haven't yet, read the power of recurring giving for churches. It's the why behind everything in this guide.
FREE Download
A Recurring Giving Guide to Strengthen Discipleship and Ministry
Packed with actionable steps, real-life examples, and teaching moments, this resource equips church leaders to build a culture of consistent, year-round giving rooted in discipleship.
Download Now
Keep reading
- The Power of Recurring Giving for Churches
- How to Beat the Summer Giving Slump with Recurring Donations
- Tithing in the New Testament: What Does It Say?
- Online Giving for Churches · the tool that powers the rhythm
VIDEO transcript
Consider this story about a pastor in the Midwest. His church had been flat on giving for two years. Not declining, just flat. He sat down one Sunday afternoon, looked at his giving dashboard, and noticed something simple: only 14% of his regular attenders had a recurring gift on file. He spent the next thirty days doing four very specific things, and by the end of the quarter, that number was 27%. Same congregation. Same income. Different rhythm.
That's the entire premise of this article. Recurring giving is not a personality trait that some churches have, and others don't. It's a habit you can teach, a friction you can remove, and a story you can tell week after week. And the leverage is real: as we walked through in the power of recurring giving, recurring givers contribute roughly 2.2x more annually than one-time givers. Same families. Different cadence.
What follows are eight plays ordered roughly from highest leverage to lowest lift, plus a 30-day rollout you can start this Sunday. None of this is theory. It's how local pastors are actually moving the needle in 2026.
1. Ask directly, every week
The single biggest reason people don't set up recurring giving is that no one has ever asked them to. Not as a guilt trip. Not as a campaign. Just as a normal, weekly part of how your church talks about generosity.
Two scripts to steal:
From the stage (15 seconds before the offering):
“If you call this place home and you're giving today, would you take 60 seconds and set this up to repeat? It costs you nothing different, but it lets us plan the year in faith instead of guessing month to month. Pull out your phone. We'll wait.”
In the giving app or online form:
“This can be a one-time gift, or you can make it your monthly rhythm. Most of our regular givers go monthly. Want to try it?”
Both versions do the same job: they normalize recurring as the default, and they ask without flinching. For a deeper look at the cadence and channels, see our piece on why your church should regularly promote automated recurring giving.
2. Make consistency the message
Most generosity teaching focuses on the size of a gift. The bigger lever is its consistency. The math is striking, and it's not from a third-party study. It's straight from Tithely's own giving data across thousands of churches.
“The size of your gift will change with your season. Whether you give consistently doesn't have to.”
On average, one-time givers contribute about $1,245 per year. Recurring givers contribute about $2,739 per year. The median split is even sharper: $204 vs. $1,228. Same families. Different cadence. We unpacked the full picture in the power of recurring giving. Link to it from a sermon series page or send it as a follow-up email to anyone who responds to the offering moment.
When you preach on giving, lead with consistency, not amount. “The size of your gift will change with your season. Whether you give consistently doesn't have to.” That one line, repeated four Sundays a year, reshapes how a congregation thinks about their offering.
3. Frame the theology in 90 seconds
You don't need a six-week sermon series to ground recurring giving in scripture. You need a clear, brief framing that you return to often.
Recurring giving is the natural shape of a generous heart. Every harvest cycle in the Old Testament was rhythmic. The early church in Acts gave “as they had need” week by week, not in a burst. Paul tells the Corinthians to set aside something “on the first day of every week” (1 Corinthians 16:2). The biblical pattern for giving is regular, planned, and joyful.
Then point readers and listeners to the deeper studies. We have a comprehensive look at what the New Testament says about tithing, and a practical resource of scriptures about giving you can drop into a bulletin, a small group guide, or a monthly stewardship email.
4. Tell the story behind the gift
Numbers move analysts. Stories move congregations. Every quarter, find one giver in your church who set up a recurring gift in the last 90 days and ask them three questions on camera:
- “What was happening in your life when you decided to set this up?”
- “What did you learn about yourself or your faith once it started?”
- “What would you say to someone who's thinking about it but hasn't pulled the trigger?”
Edit it down to 60 seconds. Play it before the offering. Post it as a Reel. Email it to your list with a single subject line: “Why Sarah gives every month.” Stories do the asking for you, and they answer the unspoken hesitations no sermon ever quite covers.
5. Build a multichannel promotion rhythm
If recurring giving only shows up in announcements, you'll get the attendance you expect. The churches that move this number treat recurring giving the way they treat their Easter campaign: planned, multi-channel, sustained.
A simple 30-day cadence:
Multichannel doesn't mean noisy. It means present.
6. Remove every ounce of friction
Every extra tap is a tax on generosity. The churches that grow recurring giving the fastest are usually the ones that have been the most ruthless about removing the small obstacles between an intention and a transaction.
Make it easy to set up
Set up should take under 60 seconds and should never require leaving your app or your giving page. If your current online giving for churches tool requires an account, a verification email, and a confirmation step before someone can give, you're losing givers in the gap. Look at your flow on a phone. If you can't complete a recurring gift in three thumb taps, your tool is the bottleneck.
Make it easy to change
Givers should be able to update their amount, switch from card to ACH, or pause a gift on their own, without emailing the church office. The mental cost of “I'll have to call someone” is enough to keep a generous person from increasing their gift. Don't give them that excuse.
Make it easy to cancel
This sounds counterintuitive. It isn't. Givers who know they can cancel in two taps are more likely to set up recurring gifts. The churches that hide the cancel button get the same number of cancellations; they just get fewer recurring gifts to start with.
Cover the fees, where you can
Many givers will happily cover transaction fees if you let them. Tithely's Cover the Fees™ option presents that choice at the moment of the gift. In our data, more than 80% of givers opt in when asked. That's a small UX choice with a real budget impact.
ACH vs. card and what to do when payments fail
ACH is cheaper for the church, but slower. The card is faster, but it expires. The pragmatic answer is: offer both, default to whatever your congregation prefers, and mitigate the painful part of failed payments. Set up automated retry logic, an email to the giver when a card expires, and a quarterly report so your finance team isn't surprised. A failed recurring payment is not the end of a recurring relationship unless your system silently lets it die.
7. Activate first-time givers within Seven days
The first seven days after someone gives for the first time is the most overlooked window in church generosity. Most one-time givers never give again, not because they didn't mean to, but because nothing happened to bring them back. Your job is to send the right three messages while generosity is still stirring in their heart.
- Day 1: Thank them. Personally. By name. From the pastor, not from the system. A two-line email beats a templated receipt.
- Day 3: Tell a story. Send one short story about what their gift made possible. Specific. Recent. Concrete.
- Day 7: Make the soft ask. “If this place is becoming home for you, would you consider making this monthly? It's two taps, and you can change it any time.”
This sequence is not a marketing funnel. It's pastoral care that takes generosity seriously. Once you set it up, it runs in the background and steadily turns first-time givers into committed monthly partners.
8. Measure and revisit quarterly
You cannot grow what you do not watch. Three numbers—and only three—tell you whether recurring giving is working at your church:
- Recurring giver count: how many active recurring gifts do you have today?
- Recurring share of total giving: of every dollar that came in this month, how many cents were recurring?
- Average recurring gift: Is the size of your typical recurring gift growing, flat, or shrinking?
Pull these every quarter. Pick one to move next quarter. Run one experiment with a new “ask” script, a new channel, and a new first-gift sequence. Measure it against your baseline. Repeat. Most churches that try to optimize everything end up moving nothing; the ones that pick a single number per quarter compound their gains over a year.
Your 30-day recurring-giving rollout
If you only have a month, do this:
- Week 1: Launch the ask. Add the recurring ask script to every offering moment and start collecting one giver story.
- Week 2: Email every one-time giver from the last 90 days with a direct invitation to make their gift recurring.
- Week 3: Add a push notification, a bulletin insert, and a foyer QR card. Launch a second story.
- Week 4: Measure. Whatever channel produced the most new recurring givers, do twice as much of it next month.
Where to go from here
Recurring giving is not a software problem. It's a leadership rhythm. Your tools should make the rhythm easier, not add another thing for your team to manage.
If your current giving setup is the pain point, consider Tithely's online giving for churches. Setup is free, recurring is built in, Cover the Fees™ is one toggle, and your finance team gets the reporting it actually needs.
And if you haven't yet, read the power of recurring giving for churches. It's the why behind everything in this guide.
FREE Download
A Recurring Giving Guide to Strengthen Discipleship and Ministry
Packed with actionable steps, real-life examples, and teaching moments, this resource equips church leaders to build a culture of consistent, year-round giving rooted in discipleship.
Download Now
Keep reading
- The Power of Recurring Giving for Churches
- How to Beat the Summer Giving Slump with Recurring Donations
- Tithing in the New Testament: What Does It Say?
- Online Giving for Churches · the tool that powers the rhythm
Sign Up for Product Updates
Chris Dunagan is a marketing strategist focused on church tech and digital engagement. He helps churches grow through SEO, email campaigns, and tools like Tithely and Breeze ChMS, with an emphasis on online giving, content strategy, and digital outreach.
You Might Also Like
More Resources
From increasing giving, managing your congregation, and engaging your church, our collection of resources will keep you up-to-date on the latest church and ministry trends.
Free Resources
.jpg)
.jpg)
