What AI Will Never Replace In Ministry

Unless you’ve been a hermit in the woods for the past two years, you’ve seen the massive explosion of artificial intelligence. 

It’s everywhere. Writing emails and social media posts. Summarizing meetings, developing sermon outlines, and helping people do extensive research very quickly. 

There’s no shortage of AI platforms and apps. Some people have jumped into the AI deep end, using AI tools in many different areas of life. Others are more hesitant. 

I’m a Millennial. I saw the Terminator movies. Sometimes it feels like we’re moving toward Skynet at an uncomfortably rapid pace (here’s an intro to Skynet for those who want to learn more). 

You might be curious or excited about what you could/can achieve with AI. Or maybe you feel a bit nervous, especially when you think about how AI will impact your ministry. 

After all, ChatGPT can write a detailed sermon in less than thirty seconds. 

If an AI tool can write a sermon, answer questions, and automate communication, where does that leave pastors? Leaders? Volunteers?

The reality is that AI is a tool, and like any other tool, it can be used in many different ways, both good and bad. It will never replace the most important parts of ministry, like praying for church members, visiting the sick, preaching, leading worship, etc. 

When the internet arrived on the scene in the late 1990s, it changed the way some parts of ministry were done, but it didn’t eliminate the need for it. And just like the internet has been incredibly helpful for ministry, so can AI. 

Let’s talk about what AI can’t replace in ministry.

The Need For Relationships

AI will never replace people’s need for God. And God uses people to meet that need. Yes, God meets each of us in powerful, individual ways. But He also meets us through our relationships with others. 

Ministry is primarily relational.  

God uses us to help others meet God when we serve in children’s ministry, preach a sermon, or greet people on Sunday mornings. He works through us when we visit the sick, serve our communities, or pray with one another. 

AI can process data. It can recognize patterns. It can generate content. But it can’t preach with power and conviction. It can’t make a meal for a new mom. It can’t comfort a grieving parent. It can’t draw someone to Jesus.

God uses people to do those things. 

There will always be a need for people who love God, love their neighbor, and want to reach the world with the gospel. A church can’t run on AI. It runs on pastors, teachers, musicians, small groups, and volunteers. 

Pastoral Presence

Some of the most meaningful ministry moments don’t happen on Sunday mornings or scheduled meetings.

They happen in hospital rooms and kitchen tables. In quiet offices. Through late-night phone calls. In the funeral home. Over coffee. 

You could use AI to generate a prayer (though I wouldn’t recommend it). But AI can’t comfort someone during their grief or pray with the young wife who just lost her husband. It will never be able to invite a neighbor to church. Or visit a lonely person or hold a child or feed the hungry. 

The reality is that there will always be a need for pastors who are there for their people. 

Discernment and Wisdom

Wouldn’t it be nice if ministry were simple? Always black-and-white, cut and dry. Nothing confusing or multi-faceted. 

But ministry isn’t simple. It involves people who have struggles and emotions and a past. There are complicated situations. Times when things aren’t clear, but you still have to make a decision. 

Ministry requires lots of wisdom and discernment from God. 

AI can give you information. It can identify patterns and suggest options. But it can’t help you know how to best serve a dad with a wayward son. It can’t help you figure out whether someone is struggling with problems that are physical, spiritual, or both.  

There are times in leadership when the right decision isn’t obvious. When data doesn’t give you the answer. When you have to pray, listen, wait, and trust God.

You can’t get discernment and wisdom from an algorithm or a bunch of computer code. It comes from experience, spiritual depth, and dependence on God.

Preaching With Conviction

AI can definitely help you with sermon prep. It can speed up your research, generate illustrations, suggest relevant scriptures, etc.

But it can’t preach with conviction. The conviction that comes from a deep love for God and years of lived experience. 

AI can’t preach with authority or give a sermon to comfort specific groups in your church.

Think about the best sermons you’ve ever heard. Were they the most technically correct, polished, perfect sermons? No. They were passionate sermons given by people who were real and authentic. 

They came from someone who had walked through trials and come out praising God. Who had been changed by the truth they were preaching.

AI will never be able to deliver a sermon fueled by the Holy Spirit that lands with power and hope and joy. Only you can do that. 

Deep Empathy

Empathy is at the heart of ministry.

It’s rejoicing with those who rejoice and mourning with those who mourn. It’s celebrating with a church member who just got the new job they were praying for. And it’s sitting in silence with parents whose daughter is struggling with addiction.

AI has no emotions.  

It can simulate empathy in language. It can choose kind words and sound compassionate. But it can’t feel compassion. It can’t comprehend grief, feel joy, understand what it’s like to struggle, or know what depression does to a person. 

People can tell when you’re empathetic. They can tell when you really care about them and when something is just words that sound good. 

Ministry isn’t just saying the right words, like some sort of magic spell. It’s about feeling what your church members feel and responding in kind. 

Strong Community

People desperately need real community. The growing number of AI-powered apps that try to be a “friend” to users shows just how alone many people feel.

AI will never be able to give people true community and friendship. That comes from praying and serving together. From sharing meals, laughing at jokes, crying during crises, and growing spiritually together.  

AI can help you organize groups of people and write emails. 

But it can’t build community. Not in a million years. 

When social media first came on the scene, people said it was going to help everyone feel more connected. And, sure, you can have thousands of friends and participate in groups and post photos of your new hamster named “Kevin”. 

But everybody knows that social media is a terrible substitute for time spent with people. 

So is AI. 

Divine Calling

You know that ministry is not just a job to help you pay the bills. It’s a calling.

It’s why you stay when things get hard. And serve when it’s inconvenient. And pray for God’s power to keep going even when you’re exhausted. You know God has called you to ministry, and it propels you forward. 

AI doesn’t feel called. It doesn’t feel anything. It’s never burdened or compelled by the Holy Spirit to do something. AI can’t sacrifice for others and persevere when the going gets tough. 

‍

God doesn’t call machines to ministry. He calls people and equips them with what they need to fulfill that calling. 

So What Is AI Good For in Ministry?

All of this doesn’t mean you should avoid AI. It means you should know its limitations and not expect it or try to use it for things only you can do. 

AI is great at:

• Drafting communications
• Summarizing info
• Organizing data
• Generating ideas
• Performing admin tasks
• Finding resources

It can do things that normally would take you away from more important things, like prayer and sermon prep. 

AI can’t and never will replace ministry. It does give you more space for ministry. 

The same is true for church technology in general. Tools that simplify giving, streamline operations, centralize data, and reduce friction aren’t about efficiency for efficiency’s sake. They’re about freeing leaders to lead and pastors to pastor.

Use AI like you use other digital tools. To help you serve God more effectively.

AI Can Assist Ministry, But It Can’t Be Ministry

AI isn’t going anywhere. AI is powerful. 

But it can’t shepherd people and point them to God. That’s your job. Your calling. Your mission. 

You don’t need to fear AI any more than you fear the internet or your iPhone. You need to approach it with wisdom and with the mindset that it’s a resource to help you minister better. 

AI will never replace people’s need for God and pastors and churches who help meet that need.  

Technology is going to keep changing and advancing at breakneck speed. But God never changes, nor does the mission of the church.

‍