Tithely Alternative

Today’s churches juggle an incredible range of needs — from leading members and running events to managing donations, worship teams, and administration. But too often, churches rely on a patchwork of tools like Pushpay for giving, Intuit for accounting, Asana for projects, Mailchimp for communication, and WordPress for their website.

The result?

• Communication gaps
  
• Duplicate work
  
• Higher costs from multiple subscriptions
  
• Increased errors and frustration
  

What churches need is a fully integrated church management platform — one place where giving, management, communication, and marketing work together seamlessly. That’s where Tithely shines.

‍

What Is Tithely?

Tithely is an all-in-one church management solution used by over 50,000 churches in 50+ countries. It combines giving, administration, communication, and marketing tools to help churches thrive.

‍

Tithely Key Features

• Multiple ways to give: online, mobile, text, kiosk, and crypto
  
• Church Management: member and volunteer management, workflows, reporting
  
• Messaging and email: event promotion, newsletters, updates
  
• Church website builder: simple, beautiful, and integrated
  
• Worship service planning: coordinate teams, setlists, and services

Tithely’s big advantage? Everything is integrated — no more jumping between apps or syncing data manually.

‍

‍

Why Churches Love Tithely

“Our church has been using Tithely for more than 12 months and it’s been tremendously useful — simple to use, allows giving to multiple funds, and works great when someone can’t make a service.” — Joe

“We were so frustrated trying to ‘integrate’ other tools. Tithely was up and running in hours and works perfectly with our website.” — Jason

“Tithely is affordable, easy to use, and dramatically increased our online and text giving.” — Josh

‍

How Tithely Compares to Other Church Platforms

Let’s break down how Tithely stacks up against three major alternatives: Pushpay, easyTithe, and PayPal for Churches.

‍

1. Pushpay vs. Tithely

Pushpay began as a donor management system in 2011 and quickly became a leader in church giving. It now offers church management tools through its partnership with Church Community Builder.

‍

Pushpay strengths:

• Giving and donor tools
  
• Established name in church tech
  

Where Pushpay falls short:

• Higher cost
• Limited product integration
• Less flexibility for smaller churches
  

Tithely covers these gaps, giving churches not only giving tools but also:

• Integrated email and texting
  
• Free graphics and media
  
• A built-in pay portal for on-site sales
  

2. easyTithe vs. Tithely

easyTithe offers online, app, and kiosk giving plus financial reports. While they advertise themselves as a free platform, users pay a $10/month fee — and customer support is often criticized as slow.

easyTithe strengths:

• Simple giving options
  
• International giving support
  

Where easyTithe falls short:

• No website builder
  
• No text or email marketing
  
• No background check tools
  

Tithely includes:

• Background checks for volunteers
  
• Text and email campaigns
  
• A church website builder
  
• Full admin tools beyond giving
  

3. PayPal for Churches vs. Tithely

PayPal is a global giant in online payments, with 305 million users. But for churches, it’s little more than a basic payment processor.

PayPal strengths:

• Familiar brand for donors
  
• Simple point-of-sale system
  

Where PayPal falls short:

• No administrative tools or CRM
  
• No free mobile giving app
  
• No church website builder
  

Tithely, on the other hand, offers:

• A free mobile giving app
  
• A robust church management solution for managing people, workflows, and finances
  
• A full-featured website builder
  

‍

Why Choose Tithely?

• True all-in-one platform: Giving, management, communication, and marketing in one system
  
• Affordable pricing: Free giving tools, or $119/month for All Access (vs. Pushpay’s $149+/month)
  
• Faster setup: Live in minutes, no merchant account required
  
• No contracts: Cancel anytime without penalty
  
• Global reach: Supports churches in the U.S., Canada, U.K., Australia, New Zealand, Singapore, and Japan
  

Who Should Use Each Platform?

Pushpay: Churches focused only ondonor management who have a large budget
easyTithe: Small churches needing basic giving tools
PayPal: Businesses needing a payment button
Tithely: Churches of all sizes wanting an integrated, scalable solution

‍

What Churches Are Saying About Tithely

“They have the best feature set and the most customer-friendly staff around.” — Russ C.
“Tithely is clean, easy to use, and thoughtfully designed for churches.” — Sean C.
“We were live in minutes, the setup team was incredible, and the app is super user-friendly.” — Danielle K.

‍

Final Thoughts

While Pushpay, easyTithe, and PayPal all serve important roles in church tech, Tithely stands out as the most complete and cost-effective solution for churches today. From giving to admin, websites to worship planning, it’s a platform built to help churches thrive.

‍

‍

Still looking for the right tools to run your church?

Best All-In-One Church Management Software

Best Mobile Giving for Churches

Best Church Apps

‍