<script type="application/ld+json"> { "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "FAQPage", "mainEntity": [ { "@type": "Question", "name": "What is the best Tithely alternative for churches?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "The best Tithely alternative depends on your church’s needs. Some churches compare platforms like Pushpay, easyTithe, PayPal, or Zeffy. However, many churches choose Tithely because it combines online giving, church management, communication tools, websites, and worship planning into a single, integrated platform with predictable pricing and no long-term contracts." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Is Tithely better than Pushpay?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Tithely and Pushpay both support online and mobile giving, but they take different approaches. Pushpay is often used by large churches with enterprise budgets and long-term contracts. Tithely offers more flexibility, lower and more predictable pricing, no contracts, and an all-in-one church management platform that goes beyond giving alone." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Is Zeffy a good option for churches?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Zeffy can work for nonprofits running occasional fundraising campaigns because it uses a donor-tip model to cover fees. However, it is not built specifically for churches and lacks tools for recurring tithes, church management, communication, mobile apps, and worship-related workflows that most churches rely on week to week." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "What church giving platform has no contracts?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Tithely does not require long-term contracts. Churches can start, scale, or cancel at any time without penalties, making it a flexible option for churches that want to avoid being locked into multi-year agreements." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "What is the difference between a church management system and a giving platform?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "A giving platform focuses primarily on accepting donations, while a church management system includes tools for managing people, volunteers, communication, events, reporting, and workflows. Tithely combines both into a single platform, allowing churches to connect giving with engagement and administration." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Can small churches use Tithely?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Yes. Tithely is used by churches of all sizes, including small and mid-sized congregations. It offers free giving tools and affordable upgrade options, making it accessible for churches that want to grow without high upfront costs." } } ] } </script> </div>

Tithely Alternative

Tithely Alternative: Pushpay, easyTithe, Zeffy, PayPal for Churches

Searching for a Tithely alternative? We compare the top alternatives to Tithely: Pushpay, easyTithe, Zeffy, and PayPal for Churches. Find out how they compare.
Watch a Demo →
Tithely Alternative: Pushpay, easyTithe, Zeffy, PayPal for Churches

The Best Tithely Alternative? Comparing Church Giving & Church Management (ChMS) Platforms

Today’s churches juggle an incredible range of needs — from leading people and running events to managing donations, worship teams, and day-to-day administration.

Too often, churches rely on a patchwork of disconnected tools:

  • Pushpay for giving
  • Intuit for accounting
  • Asana for projects
  • Mailchimp for communication
  • WordPress for their website

The result?

  • Communication gaps
  • Duplicate work
  • Higher costs from multiple subscriptions
  • Increased errors and frustration

What churches actually need is a fully integrated church management platform — one place where giving, management, communication, and marketing work together seamlessly.

That’s where Tithely stands out.

What Is Tithely?

Tithely is an all-in-one church management solution used by over 50,000 churches in 50+ countries. It brings together digital giving, administration, communication, and engagement tools designed specifically for churches.

Instead of stitching together multiple platforms, Tithely gives churches a single system that grows with them.

Tithely Key Features

  • Multiple ways to give: online, mobile app, text, kiosk, admin entry, and crypto
  • Church Management: people, volunteers, workflows, and reporting
  • Messaging & email: newsletters, event promotion, announcements
  • Church website builder: simple, modern, and fully integrated
  • Worship service planning: coordinate teams, setlists, and services

Tithely’s biggest advantage: everything is integrated — no syncing, no third-party workarounds, no duplicated data.

Schedule a Demo →

Why Churches Love Tithely

“Our church has been using Tithely for more than 12 months, and it’s been tremendously useful — simple to use, allows giving to multiple funds, and works great when someone can’t make a service.” — Joe
“We were so frustrated trying to ‘integrate’ other tools. Tithely was up and running in hours and works perfectly with our website.” — Jason
“Tithely is affordable, easy to use, and dramatically increased our online and text giving.” — Josh

How Tithely Compares to Other Church Platforms

If you’re researching Tithely alternatives, these are the platforms churches most often compare.

1. Pushpay vs. Tithely

Pushpay began as a digital giving solution and later expanded through partnerships to offer additional church management tools.

Pushpay strengths:

  • Giving and donor tools
  • Established brand in large churches

Where Pushpay falls short:

  • High and escalating monthly costs
  • Long-term contracts
  • Limited product integration
  • Less flexibility for small and mid-sized churches

How Tithely compares

  • Predictable, affordable pricing
  • No contracts
  • Giving + management + communication in one system
  • Faster product innovation

2. easyTithe vs. Tithely

easyTithe provides basic online and kiosk giving tools, with a low monthly fee.

easyTithe strengths:

  • Simple giving options
  • International giving support

Where easyTithe falls short:

  • No website builder
  • No text or email communication tools
  • Limited admin and volunteer management
  • No background check tools

What Tithely adds

  • Built-in text and email messaging
  • Background checks for volunteers
  • A fully integrated church website builder
  • Robust admin tools beyond giving

3. PayPal for Churches vs. Tithely

PayPal is one of the most recognizable payment platforms in the world, but it’s not designed for churches.

PayPal strengths:

  • Familiar brand for donors
  • Simple payment buttons

Where PayPal falls short:

  • No church management system
  • No donor engagement tools
  • No mobile giving app or church website

How Tithely compares

  • Purpose-built mobile giving app
  • Full church management system
  • Integrated website, messaging, and reporting

4. Zeffy vs Tithely

Zeffy is a nonprofit fundraising platform best known for its 100% fee-free model, where donors are encouraged to leave optional tips to cover processing costs.

Zeffy strengths

  • No required platform or processing fees
  • Simple setup for basic fundraising campaigns

Where Zeffy falls short for churches

  • Not built specifically for churches
  • Limited recurring giving tools
  • No church app, text-to-give, or kiosks
  • No church management, communication, or website tools
  • Tip-based model can feel awkward for weekly tithes

Zeffy vs Tithely takeaway
Zeffy can work for nonprofits running occasional fundraisers. Tithely is designed for ongoing church generosity, weekly giving, and long-term ministry engagement.

Tithely vs. Competitors: Feature Comparison

Feature Tithely Pushpay easyTithe Zeffy PayPal
Online Giving
Text & Email Messaging
Church Management System (via CCB)
Website Builder
Mobile Giving App
Background Checks
Pricing Free Giving Tools
$119/mo for All Access
$149+ $10+ $0 Platform Fee
Optional Donor Tips
High Transaction Fees
2.9%–5.0% + additional fees

Why Choose Tithely?

  • True all-in-one platform: Giving, management, communication, and marketing in one system
  • Affordable pricing: Free giving tools, or $119/month for All Access (vs. Pushpay’s $149+/month)
  • Fast setup: Live in minutes, no merchant account required
  • No contracts: Cancel anytime
  • Global reach: Supports churches in the U.S., Canada, U.K., Australia, New Zealand, Singapore, and Japan

Who Should Use Each Platform?

Pushpay: Large churches focused primarily on donor management with enterprise budgets

easyTithe: Small churches needing basic online giving

PayPal: Organizations needing a simple payment button

Zeffy: Nonprofits running occasional fundraising campaigns

Tithely: Churches of any size wanting an integrated, scalable platform

What Churches Are Saying About Tithely

“They have the best feature set and the most customer-friendly staff around.” — Russ C.
“Tithely is clean, easy to use, and thoughtfully designed for churches.” — Sean C.
“We were live in minutes, the setup team was incredible, and the app is super user-friendly.” — Danielle K.

Final Thoughts

While Pushpay, easyTithe, PayPal, and Zeffy each serve specific use cases, Tithely stands out as the most complete and church-focused solution available.

By combining giving, administration, communication, websites, and worship planning into a single platform, Tithely helps churches reduce complexity, lower costs, and focus more energy on ministry, not software.

Schedule a Demo →

Still looking for the right tools to run your church?

Best All-In-One Church Management Software

Best Mobile Giving for Churches

Best Church Apps

Refer a Friend & Earn $500