7 Steps to Creating a Must-Read Church Bulletin
People ignoring your church bulletin in-person or online? Follow these 7-steps to turn your bulletin into a must-read document.
September 23, 2020
October is Pastor Appreciation Month.
Pastor Appreciation Day, also known as Clergy Appreciation Day, is the second Sunday of October.
Your pastor is probably underpaid, overextended, suffering from shift work syndrome, and hasn’t had regular working hours his entire career.
What do pastors receive for their hard work?
According to Payscale.com, the average pastor’s salary is $48,828 per year.
And yet, the average pastor goes into $60,000 of debt to receive a seminary education.
Most of them don’t go to seminary to become rich.
Travis Collins writes in his book For Ministers about to Start...or about to Give Up that 75% of pastors experience “severe stress causing anguish, worry, bewilderment, anger, depression, fear and alienation” during their ministry.
But it doesn’t have to be this way.
Sometimes, all it takes to keep pastoral burnout at bay is for a church to crush Pastor Appreciation Month.
Here are guidelines for how you and your church can excel this October in showing your pastor that he/she is appreciated, loved, and respected in your church.
Pastor appreciation gift guidelines:
First, don’t be sheepish about giving them gifts.
In fact, you should be pushy about it.
They usually are wary of receiving gifts, but this is the perfect opportunity to bulldoze their misplaced sense of guilt and say: “No, we insist!”
Second, It’s important that when you give an individual gift, the gift isn’t about you.
For example, a bad example of a pastor appreciation gift would be a two-hour coffee meeting with me. That is a burden, not a gift. Don’t give the gift of work.
Third, give a gift from as many people as possible.
The more people you include in the gift, the higher quality gift you can give. For example, instead of buying 20 $20 gift cards to Starbucks, one person could take it upon themselves to coordinate the purchase of a $400 espresso machine.
You might wonder: “Wouldn’t he want $400 in Starbucks gift cards?”
Trust me — he/she wants the espresso machine.
Fourth, let your inner capitalist run wild.
Just because the pastor might make a mediocre salary, that doesn’t mean you should buy him a mediocre gift. Ask yourself: “How could we make him feel extraordinarily appreciated? How could we make him feel truly blessed?”
It’s not that you can’t give him a $5 gift card if that’s all you can contribute. But with the possibility of pooling resources and intentional forethought, you could easily make a list of things they would prefer over a gift card.
While we’re on the topic, let me preface our idealist with a list of gifts you absolutely shouldn’t buy.
Most people think about this time as an opportunity for individuals to express appreciation.
Here’s the deal:
The more organized you are as a church, the more meaningful you can make your appreciation.
In fact, you should do both.
This is why we’ll break our 10 killer pastor appreciation ideas into individual and corporate gifts.
Here are the 5 most meaningful gifts:
This is very low-budget. This option exists so that you have no excuse not to give anything.
A handwritten letter or note also provides an opportunity for kids to participate. Take time at home to make this a craft for your kids. It will teach kids the value of expressing gratitude to those who serve in the church, and it will teach them about the sacrifice pastors make in dedicating their lives to ministry.
Pastors love to eat (maybe a little too much—but hey, you can bring that up on New Year’s Eve.
Buy them a gift card to his favorite restaurant.
Cook him his favorite meal.
Order takeout on their behalf.
Again, a free meal shouldn’t turn into: “I bought you dinner out with me and my wife — and by the way, we need counseling!”
The gift of a meal is: “What’s your favorite pizza place in the area? Mario’s? What’s the best night for me to buy your family three pizzas from Mario’s so that you’ll have leftovers?”
They rarely are given the chance to go anywhere.
Give them tickets to an event they would enjoy.
A local professional sporting event.
A concert by their favorite band.
A Broadway production down in the city.
Just make sure to check with his secretary that the dates work with his schedule.
This is an opportunity to do something for them that they would never do for themselves.
If you are a professional, it is appropriate to offer your services for free.
Just make sure you don’t offer a 20% discount to your services so that you end up profiting from Appreciation Month. Make it a genuine gift.
If you’re going to give them a gift or service that you offer, make it pro bono.
I know we criticized gift cards earlier, but they are actually a great individual gift. If a pastor receives cash, he/she may feel obligated to spend it on somebody else. The point of this occasion is to help them receive the care he needs to feel valued and refreshed to continue doing good work.
The beauty of the gift card as a gift is that they are forced to practice self-care.
And they are notoriously bad at this. This time is your opportunity to prompt pastors to do something good for themselves without the gift of feeling like they should spend it on someone else.
But if you do give a gift card, aim for something more than Starbucks. Certain gift cards can go a very long way. A few examples of gift cards that will bless them 10x as much as a Starbucks gift card are:
Better than coffee out is a coffee gift card to their favorite local espresso spot. This way, they can actually use the gift card to enjoy a date with their wife or a relaxing Monday morning.
Even better than individual gifts are group gifts.
Remember: 40 $10 Starbucks cards vs an Espresso machine.
Mobilize a group of people, come up with a good gift that everyone is willing to give, and pitch in as much as possible.
Include a card with a message for pastor appreciation that includes everyone’s name.
Coordinate with your church leaders to pay for a speaker (or elder) to preach one Sunday during Pastor Appreciation Month.
They will appreciate a full week off.
Remember: They never just attend a Sunday service.
This takes a spiritual toll.
This gift allows them to exhale and experience a service as a regular Christian without taking on the burden of a full sabbatical.
Most pastors are bombarded with ads for Logos Bible Software, Olive Tree, and Accordance.
He looks upon them with envy.
Don’t let your pastor struggle with envy.
Give him a Bible study software that enables him to do his job more efficiently and effectively.
Make sure it’s the one he/she wants. How do you know which one it is? Ask directly. Ask the secretary. Do what you need to do to find out.
Is it Accordance or Logos Bible Software? If he already has one of these, you could pay to upgrade him to a certain package that he has always wanted.
Someone in the community has a cabin or time share somewhere.
If that person is you, consider offering a week in your vacation spot to your pastor.
Chances are that they may feel like they informally don't have permission to go away on vacation because of the needs of the church.
Let them know that they need rest and time to decompress from church as much as anyone needs time away from work.
Give your pastor a weekend getaway, either with his whole family, or with just his or her spouse.
Pro tip: If you get a couple’s getaway, make sure you offer a trusted family to babysit kids for the weekend so that a gift doesn’t become an expense.
Offer your pastor a bonus check.
The only risk of a bonus check is that it could become an unhealthy precedent for the practice of pastor appreciation month. In other words, if the pastor comes to expect a gift each year, different gifts can have different meanings.
But if he gets a cash bonus one October, he will expect something similar next October. As a general rule of thumb, if you give a cash bonus, make it for an amount less than the value of other gifts you might give.
And yet, a pastor will really appreciate a bonus check.
In the corporate world, depending on the industry, a bonus check could be anywhere from 1%-5% of a person’s salary, depending on the growth of the company and the resources available.
The financial security and sense of belonging that a pastor has in a church will only refortify his commitment and resolve for the ministry of the church.
A happy pastor is an energized and effective pastor.
Finally, and this may be the best gift on the list—give your pastor the gift of Tithe.ly ChMS.
This church management software allows your pastor to transfer his 72 different administrative processes into a single place.
Tithe.ly ChMS does it all in the same place so that he doesn’t have to frantically manage 1,000 google docs and sift through 20 Gmail threads just to find out where Small Group #7 meets and what food still needs to be brought.
Get Tithe.ly ChMS for your pastor.
You’re buying your pastor more than a church management solution.
You’re buying him time and energy.
This is worth more than a bonus check, a software, and a gift card.
Get Tithe.ly ChMS as a gift to your pastor from your church, and you give him the gift of administrative ease.
This way, he can focus more on the real ministry rather than the administrative tasks that often weigh down 80% of his time.
Remember, this October:
Don’t skimp on Pastor Appreciation Month.
Make it a month they will always remember.
Make it his Christmas season (since most Christmas seasons overwork pastors with double sermon duty).
Editor's note: This post was updated on May 11, 2020 to reflect the latest trends and comprehension.