Tithely wasn't built by a software team guessing at what churches need. It was built by a pastor who needed it himself. Founder Dean Sweetman was leading his own congregation in Atlanta when he had a simple realization: if he could order coffee from his phone, why couldn't his church give from theirs? That question became Tithely's first giving app, built for his own church before it was ever offered to anyone else's. More than 53,000 churches use it today, but the lens hasn't changed: every feature we build gets judged by whether it actually helps a pastor and their team serve people better. That's the same lens we're using in this comparison.
If you're comparing Tithely vs Subsplash to choose the best online giving platform for your church, you're in the right place. Both platforms help churches collect online donations and engage members, but they differ greatly in user experience, pricing, and advanced features.
In this article, we'll break down the differences between Tithely and Subsplash, helping you make the best choice for your ministry.
(Editor's Note: While we're partial to Tithely, we aim to provide accurate and honest comparisons. If you notice anything inaccurate, let us know here, and we'll update the post.)
Tithely is an online giving and church management platform built by pastors, for pastors. It provides a complete suite of tools for digital giving, church management, and communication. Our mission is to be the most affordable platform for churches of all sizes.
Subsplash is primarily a church media platform that offers:
While Subsplash has expanded into giving, its core focus is on media and engagement tools.
The best Subsplash alternative is Tithely, and here’s why. Beyond the giving, church management, and website tools both platforms offer, Tithely offers churches an affordable tap-to-give solution, AI-powered sermon writing, transparent donor fees, and flexible non-cash giving, all built with a pastor's eye for what actually helps. Here's a closer look at what makes the difference.
For churches looking for more than a giving solution, Tithely All Access brings Tithely’s core church technology into one platform for $119/month. It includes church management, a custom church app, website builder, messaging, events, media, giving, and more, providing your team one connected system instead of a patchwork of separate tools and subscriptions. The goal is simple: spend less time managing software and more time focused on ministry.
Give with a tap, no extra platform required. Tithely Tap discs mount to chairs, pews, or bulletins and connect straight into Tithely Giving, so members can give in seconds without opening an app. Tithely Tap starts at $2.50/disc with no monthly subscription.
While both platforms offer AI tools, they solve different problems. Tithely includes Sermonly, an AI-powered sermon writing tool designed to help pastors develop ideas, build outlines, research Scripture, and write the message itself. Subsplash's AI tools are more focused on sermon production and media, helping churches turn existing messages into clips, summaries, and other digital content. If you're looking for AI that helps before you step into the pulpit, Sermonly is built specifically for that part of the ministry workflow.
With Tithely's Cover the Fees™, donors can choose to cover the transaction fee on their gift, so your church receives the full intended donation, 100% of the net gift. It's available to every Tithely Giving subscriber, in any country.
Both Tithely and Subsplash give churches options beyond traditional card and ACH donations. Tithely supports stock and cryptocurrency giving through its Engiven partnership, making it easier for donors to give appreciated assets or digital currency without adding another disconnected system to your giving strategy. Subsplash also supports stock and cryptocurrency donations through a similar partnership with Engiven, so this is one area where the two platforms offer comparable capabilities.
Your Tithely All-Access account includes your own custom website. Every Tithely Site comes with built-in SEO settings, editable page titles, meta keywords, and meta descriptions, so your church shows up in search without extra plugins or add-ons.
Donors can split a single one-time gift across up to 5 funds right on the Tithely Giving form, no extra steps, no separate transactions.
Tithely pricing:
Customer support:
Subsplash pricing:
Subsplash pricing varies depending on the products and features a church needs. Subsplash One appears to start around $149/month, while churches using additional app, website, media, and communication features may pay significantly more. Estimated pricing commonly falls into ranges such as:
For a church of around 200 people, a more typical monthly cost may fall in the $249–$350 range once the necessary features are included.
By comparison, Tithely All Access is $119/month and includes church management, giving, a custom church app, website, messaging, events, media, and more. The price doesn’t increase as your church grows, helping support Tithely’s goal of being an affordable church technology platform for churches of every size.
Customer support:
Is Tithely cheaper than Subsplash?
Tithely's core giving is free, and its All Access bundle (giving, church management, apps, and websites together) costs a flat $119/month. Subsplash's giving is also free before transaction fees, but its mobile app, website, and media tools are priced separately and can add up to hundreds of dollars a month depending on what you need.
Does Tithely offer tap-to-give like Subsplash?
Yes. Tithely Tap NFC discs let donors give with a single tap of their phone, no app required, starting at $2.50/disc with no monthly subscription.
Does Tithely have AI tools for sermon writing?
Yes. Tithely includes Sermonly, an AI sermon-writing tool built specifically for ministry, so pastors can spend less time on prep and more time with their congregation.
Can donors cover the transaction fees on their gift?
Yes. With Tithely's Cover the Fees™ option, donors can choose to add a small amount to their gift to cover the processing fee, so the church receives 100% of the intended donation. It's available to every Tithely Giving subscriber, in any country.
Does Tithely support stock or cryptocurrency giving?
Yes. Through Tithely's partnership with Engiven, churches can accept stock and cryptocurrency donations in addition to standard card and ACH giving.
Can a donor split one gift between multiple funds?
Yes. Donors can split a single one-time gift across up to 5 funds right on the giving form, with no separate transactions required.
Does Tithely help with church website SEO?
Yes. Every Tithely Site page includes built-in SEO settings, including editable page titles, meta keywords, and meta descriptions, so churches can show up in search without needing extra plugins.
What's the main difference between Tithely and Subsplash?
Tithely is a giving-first platform, built by a pastor, that bundles giving, church management, apps, and websites into one flat-rate plan. Subsplash is media-first, with strong app and livestreaming tools, but pricing for its apps, websites, and media add-ons is separate and typically higher.
What is Subsplash used for?
Subsplash is used by churches to collect online donations and deliver media through apps and websites.
Is Subsplash only for churches?
Yes, Subsplash is designed specifically for churches and ministries.
How does Tithely work?
Tithely provides an integrated giving platform plus admin tools like Church Management, Messaging, and more—all synced on one system.
Does Tithely have an app?
Yes! Tithely offers a mobile app for giving, and you can have your own custom church app when you use our Automatic Church App Builder (Powered by AI).
