<div itemscope itemtype="https://schema.org/FAQPage"> <h2 itemprop="name">Frequently Asked Questions</h2> <div itemscope itemprop="mainEntity" itemtype="https://schema.org/Question"> <h3 itemprop="name">Who Should Use easyTithe?</h3> <div itemprop="acceptedAnswer" itemtype="https://schema.org/Answer"> <p>Churches that are alright with paying a monthly fee could use easyTithe, but they'll want to be careful as they scale in size (as cost will increase). <a href="https://get.tithe.ly/">Visit Tithe.ly</a></p> </div> </div> <div itemscope itemprop="mainEntity" itemtype="https://schema.org/Question"> <h3 itemprop="name">Who Should Use PayPal for Churches?</h3> <div itemprop="acceptedAnswer" itemtype="https://schema.org/Answer"> <p>PayPal for Churches may be sufficient for nonprofit organizations that don't need advanced giving capabilities. <a href="https://get.tithe.ly/">Visit Tithe.ly</a></p> </div> </div> <div itemscope itemprop="mainEntity" itemtype="https://schema.org/Question"> <h3 itemprop="name">Who Should Use Tithely?</h3> <div itemprop="acceptedAnswer" itemtype="https://schema.org/Answer"> <p>Small- to medium-sized churches that want a cost-effective and comprehensive giving solution that can help them increase generosity. <a href="https://get.tithe.ly/">Visit Tithe.ly</a></p> </div> </div> </div>

easyTithe vs PayPal for Churches vs Tithely

easyTithe vs PayPal for Churches vs Tithely: Which Online Giving Platform is the Best?

The main difference between easyTithe, PayPal, and Tithely is pricing and functionality. While each of these platforms have similar key features for receiving online donations, they ultimately offer much different experiences for church management teams and nonprofit organizations. 
Schedule a Demo →

If you’re torn between easyTithe, PayPal for Churches, and Tithely for your church’s online giving needs, you’re not alone.

All three platforms help churches process donations, but they differ significantly in cost, flexibility, simplicity, and features. In this guide, we’ll break down each solution to help you choose the best fit for your church.

(Editor’s Note: While we’re partial to Tithely, we aim to provide accurate and honest comparisons. If you notice anything inaccurate, let us know here, and we’ll update the post.)

Why Does Your Church Need an Online Giving Platform?

Whether you’re a church plant of 50 people or a megachurch of 1,000+, you need an online giving solution.

Here’s why:

  • Today’s givers expect to give online, on mobile, or by text
  • Online giving boosts recurring donations and overall generosity
  • Digital donations save admin teams hours of manual processing
  • An online platform makes it easy to track, report, and thank donors

When giving is easy, generosity grows.

Schedule a Demo →

Which Online Giving Platform Is the Best?

Most online giving platforms:

  • Charge processing fees
  • Offer donor receipts
  • Support recurring and one-time gifts
  • Work across mobile, desktop, and tablet

But the best online giving platform:

  • Has low or no setup fees
  • Offers affordable monthly pricing
  • Provides powerful features without surprise add-on costs
  • Supports scalable growth as your church expands

How to Choose the Right Platform

When evaluating platforms, consider:

  • Your church size (small, medium, or large)
  • Your ministry goals (just giving or full church management)
  • Ease of setup and use
  • Processing costs and scalabilit

Let’s compare easyTithe, PayPal, and Tithely side by side.

Tithely Overview

Tithely is an all-in-one giving and church management solution designed just for churches.

Key highlights:

  • Multiple payment methods
  • Mobile app + website giving
  • Text-to-Give
  • Kiosk giving
  • Admin gift entry
  • Customizable, branded forms
  • Affordable, free-to-use giving platform

How Tithely Works:
Donors can give online, via mobile app, or by text. Churches can embed Tithely on their website or build a custom Tithely-powered app. And best of all, there’s no monthly fee to use Tithely’s basic giving tools.

easyTithe Overview

easyTithe offers online giving with admin tools for tracking, reporting, and managing donors.

Key highlights:

  • Debit, credit, and ACH giving
  • Kiosk giving
  • Admin dashboard
  • Automated receipts

How easyTithe Works:
Donors give on mobile or desktop. Churches pay monthly fees, and pricing increases as your congregation grows.

PayPal for Churches Overview

PayPal for Churches is a basic payment processor adapted for nonprofits.

Key highlights:

  • Donate Now button
  • Credit/debit card and PayPal account payments
  • Recurring donation support

How PayPal Works:
Add a Donate button to your site that links to PayPal’s checkout page. Simple setup — but limited flexibility or customization.

Tithely vs. Pushpay vs. easyTithe

How the Platforms Work

Feature Tithely Pushpay easyTithe
Giving Channels Website, app, text Website, app Website, app
Integration Options QuickBooks, Salesforce, Planning Center Basic donor tools Existing church systems
Receipts & Reporting Automatic, real-time Yes Email receipts

Pricing Comparison

Feature Tithely Pushpay easyTithe
Base Cost Free / $119 for All Access $149+/mo $0–$69/mo
Extras & Fees No contracts; text, website, ChMS included Scales by size, contracts required $10 if under $300/mo; $15 text extra

Tithely stands out for offering a freemium plan — something neither Pushpay nor easyTithe provides.

Flexibility and Scalability

Feature Tithely Pushpay easyTithe
Giving Tools Multiple ways to give, scalable platform Robust, but requires ChurchStaq/ParishStaq Simple giving only
Marketing & Engagement All-in-one platform Requires extra products Very limited

Winner: Tithely — one login, one dashboard, and one price

Simplicity and Ease of Use

Feature Tithely Pushpay easyTithe
Donor Experience Intuitive and fast Polished but complex Easy, but basic
Admin Usability Minimal training needed Steeper learning curve More complex with growth

Feature Comparison

Feature Tithely easyTithe PayPal
Online Giving
Recurring Donations
Text-to-Give
Mobile App
Kiosk Giving
Donor Management
Custom Branding
Admin Reporting
Website Builder
App Builder

Who Should Use Each Platform?

  • easyTithe: Small to midsize churches comfortable with monthly fees but needing basic donation tools and reporting.
  • PayPal for Churches: Very small nonprofits or churches needing only a simple Donate button — but expect no church-specific tools.
  • Tithely: Churches seeking a free, scalable, full-featured platform that goes beyond giving to support communication, admin, and marketing.

What Churches Say About Tithely

“It’s clean, easy to use, and has clearly had tons of thoughtful investment.” — Sean C.
“Best bang for your buck. The most feature-rich platform, hands down.” — Russ C.
“Easy to integrate with our website, and even less tech-savvy members love it. Giving has gone up!” — Steven

Final Thoughts

Every church needs an online giving solution — but it shouldn’t be complicated or expensive.

Tithely offers the best combination of power, affordability, and church-specific tools to help your church thrive.

Learn more about how Tithely can transform your church’s giving.

Schedule a Demo →

More Like This