Choosing the right church management software (ChMS) can transform how your church operates, engages members, and grows its ministry. In this in-depth comparison, we’ll explore two major platforms — Tithely and FellowshipOne — to help you determine which is the best fit for your congregation.
Whether you’re a small church or a multi-campus ministry, this guide will give you the clarity you need to make a smart, budget-friendly decision.
What Is FellowshipOne?
FellowshipOne is a popular church management software that helps churches stay organized and connected. It offers tools for donation management, member communication, and church operations.
Key FellowshipOne Features
- Church management tools for administration and team coordination
- Church accounting software for financial tracking
- Online donation tools (via third-party providers)
- Church website builder (through external platforms)
While FellowshipOne covers many essentials, its core value lies in its administrative and communication tools.
How FellowshipOne Works
FellowshipOne is typically used by church administrators to handle member communications, manage operations, and track giving. The software is priced via a monthly subscription, but pricing is not transparent on the website — third-party reports suggest plans start at $179/month, which can climb higher depending on your needs.
Why Look for a FellowshipOne Alternative?
While FellowshipOne offers robust functionality, many churches find it:
- Expensive — starting at $179/month and increasing as needs grow
- Difficult to use — with a complex user interface that requires training
If you’re seeking a more affordable, user-friendly ChMS that includes all-in-one tools, there are compelling alternatives.
Meet Tithely: The Best FellowshipOne Alternative
Tithely is a powerful, all-in-one church management platform that offers everything FellowshipOne provides — plus more — at a predictable, flat rate.
What’s Included With Tithely
- Free online giving platform supporting credit cards, debit cards, ACH, and more
- Custom reporting on finances, attendance, and engagement
- Church management tools for staff, volunteers, worship planning, and workflows
- Easy-to-use website builder
- Custom mobile app builder
- Events tool with scheduling, registration, and attendance tracking
These features help churches streamline operations, boost giving, and strengthen member engagement.
How Tithely Works
Tithely’s online giving platform is free to use — no monthly subscription required.
The cost for full access to all features (Tithely All Access) is just $119/month, significantly less than FellowshipOne.
Tithely vs. FellowshipOne: Feature Comparison
| Feature |
FellowshipOne |
| Monthly Price |
$119/month (All Access) |
~$179+ (increases by church size and needs) |
| Setup Fee |
$0 |
Not publicly listed |
| Online Giving |
Free platform, low transaction fees |
Third-party providers, extra costs |
| Website Builder |
Included with All Access |
External tool, extra setup required |
| Mobile App |
Included with All Access |
Not included |
| Event & Volunteer Tools |
Unlimited events, check-ins, and registrants |
Limited, pricing may scale |
| Customer Support |
Unlimited, free |
Paid training sessions, lengthy onboarding |
| Data Privacy |
Global servers (US, Europe, Australia), GDPR compliant |
Unclear server locations, less transparency |
Why Choose Tithely Over FellowshipOne?
1. All-in-One, Easy-to-Use Platform
Tithely offers a seamless, integrated experience with no need for add-ons or third-party tools. You get everything you need — today and in the future — for one price.
2. Cost-Effective Pricing
Tithely charges a straightforward, low-cost monthly fee. There are no setup fees, no cancellation fees, and no contracts — just clear, predictable pricing.
3. Exceptional Customer Support
Tithely offers free, unlimited support via phone, live chat, and email — whether you’re a pastor, admin, or volunteer. In contrast, FellowshipOne often requires costly, time-intensive training to get started.
4. Superior Privacy and Data Security
With servers in the US, Europe, and Australia, Tithely delivers top-tier data privacy and speed. It’s fully GDPR compliant, making it a great choice for global ministries.
5. Scalable for Churches of Every Size
From small church plants to multi-campus megachurches, Tithely adapts to your needs without increasing costs as you grow.
Who Should Use FellowshipOne?
- Churches that have the budget for premium pricing
- Ministries with in-house IT teams that can manage a more complex system
Who Should Use Tithely?
- Churches of all sizes looking for an affordable, all-in-one solution
- Teams that want intuitive tools, robust support, and seamless integration
- Ministries focused on growth without ballooning software costs
Tithely makes onboarding easy with training videos, guides, and dedicated support.
FellowshipOne vs. Tithely Pricing Summary
| Software |
Starting Price |
Cost at Scale |
| FellowshipOne |
~$179/month |
Scales up with features |
| Tithely |
$119/month (All Access) |
Flat rate, no hidden fees |
For churches prioritizing cost control, usability, and robust tools, Tithely is the clear winner.
What Churches Are Saying About Tithely
“Tithely was easy to integrate with our existing website. Even our less tech-savvy members found it easy to use — and it’s helped increase our giving.” — Steven D.
“I appreciate the person-to-person support from Tithely. Few companies offer this kind of hands-on help anymore, and it’s something I REALLY value.” — Eve
“This app is marvelously glorious…thank you!” — Lorrie
Final Thoughts
FellowshipOne is a respected ChMS, but its high cost and steep learning curve make it a tough fit for many churches. Tithely, by contrast, offers an affordable, all-in-one solution with outstanding support and powerful tools to help your church thrive.
Be sure to evaluate all your options — and choose the ChMS that best supports your mission, budget, and ministry goals.
More Like This
.png)
