When it comes to online and mobile giving for churches, two names often top the list: Tithely and Pushpay. While both platforms offer powerful tools to support generosity and engagement, they take very different approaches in pricing, features, and flexibility.
In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about Tithely vs. Pushpay, so you can confidently choose the right solution for your church.
Pushpay is a digital giving platform that helps churches and nonprofits accept donations online. Founded in New Zealand, Pushpay has grown into a global provider, often branded as Pushpay NZ, Pushpay AU, or Pushpay USA.
Pushpay focuses primarily on payment processing, with additional tools available as paid add-ons or integrations.
Pushpay embeds giving forms into church websites and mobile experiences. Payments can be made via mobile devices, desktop, or text, and donors receive email receipts for all transactions.
Churches pay:
While Pushpay does not publicly list exact pricing tiers, churches regularly report:
For many churches, costs rise as generosity grows, making budgeting unpredictable.
Pros:
Cons:
Many churches begin searching for Pushpay alternatives because of:
For churches wanting giving + management + engagement in one place, Pushpay often feels incomplete.
Tithely is an all-in-one church giving and management platform built by pastors, for pastors.
Unlike Pushpay, Tithely combines digital giving, church management, communication, and engagement tools into a single, affordable ecosystem.
Tithely processes donations much like Pushpay, but connects every gift to the broader life of the church.
Giving data integrates seamlessly with:
Tithely also offers features like Cover the Fees™ and QuickGive™ to remove friction and increase generosity.
Tithely earns loyalty through value, not lock-ins. No long-term contracts required.
Mobile app, text-to-give, online forms, kiosks, and admin entry, all included.
Tithely was founded by pastors who understand church workflows, budgets, and discipleship goals.
From donor-covered fees to modern apps and websites, Tithely consistently ships new features churches actually use.
“The Tithely user interface is modern, sleek, and intuitive — it’s made a huge difference in our online giving.” — Clint
“Even our less tech-savvy members have found Tithely easy to use. It’s increased our giving over the past year.” — Steven
Pushpay remains a capable option for large churches with enterprise budgets and a willingness to commit to long-term contracts. However, its rising costs, limited flexibility, and slower pace of innovation make it a challenging fit for many growing ministries.
Tithely offers a more balanced approach — combining affordable, predictable pricing with modern giving tools and an integrated church platform built specifically for ministry. Rather than focusing solely on transactions, Tithely helps churches strengthen generosity, engagement, and connection across the entire church experience.
If you’re exploring Pushpay alternatives, Tithely stands out as a practical, scalable solution for churches that want flexibility today and room to grow tomorrow.
